Earnings AnalysisFeed overview
Crossroads

Will PayPal be stuck under $70 forever Here s why it fell today

9/4/2025, 10:44:59 PM
Economic Summary
  • A change in tariff policy (removal of the de minimis threshold after Aug 29) imposes an estimated 2% US and ~3% global revenue headwind for PayPal (PYPL), a small but visible drag on growth assumptions.
  • The market is currently focused on top-line revenue growth; PayPal's mid-single-digit revenue guidance may underwhelm investors despite stronger free cash flow expectations.
  • PayPal's sizable buyback program (roughly $6B this year within a ~$17B authorization) materially reduces share count and supports the equity, representing a large implied repurchase relative to current market cap.
  • Operationally, PayPal expects Braintree-related headwinds to ease with reacceleration in Q4 and is pushing higher-margin value-added services, which could boost transaction margin dollars even if total payment volume lags.
Bullish
  • Large buyback program and strong free cash flow provide a valuation floor for the stock.
  • Braintree headwinds are expected to abate with full reacceleration in Q4.
  • Narrative shifts can drive outsized rallies as seen with SoFi.
Bearish
  • PayPal has repeatedly failed to sustain a breakout above $70, prompting retail capitulation and selling pressure.
  • Removal of the de minimis tariff threshold creates a ~2–3% revenue headwind for PayPal in affected corridors.
  • Market is prioritizing top-line revenue growth, which penalizes companies with mid-single-digit growth narratives.
Bullish tickers
PYPLSOFI
Bearish tickers
PYPL
PYPL
2 price targets
7090
Bullish
Expect strong free cash flow, a large buyback program (~$6B this year, $17B authorized), margin improvement, and product ramps that can drive re-rating over time.
Bearish
Repeated inability to hold levels above $70, investor capitulation, Braintree-related growth headwinds, and a small tariff-driven revenue drag make near-term sentiment negative.
SOFI
Bullish
Reported a strong quarter and benefited from a narrative change that drove significant stock appreciation; demonstrates how sentiment shifts can unlock upside.
Bearish
Recent gains may reflect a narrative shift and momentum rather than a discrete change in fundamentals.
People mentioned
Jamie MillerDonald TrumpAlex Chriss