CNBC Television
Chicago Fed President Goolsbee: Uneasy about front-loading rate cuts due to limited inflation data
11/6/2025, 2:27:47 PM
Economic Summary
- The Chicago Fed Labor Market Indicator aggregates 11 private-sector sources to substitute for missing government data during the shutdown, estimating the unemployment rate at about 4.36% for October with a 40% probability it's higher and 20% probability it's lower.
- Most private-sector labor indicators show stability in hiring, layoffs, and vacancies, but total payroll job creation has notably deteriorated — a signal that should be treated cautiously given uncertainty around immigration and population growth effects.
- The labor market exhibits a low-hiring, low-firing pattern consistent with elevated uncertainty among firms; historically this combination is unusual for recession starts and makes dating business-cycle turning points harder.
- The government shutdown creates an asymmetry: timely private signals give a quick read on labor-market changes, while official inflation statistics are delayed, raising the risk of misjudging inflation trends and mistiming monetary policy easing.
- Macro backdrop remains mixed-positive: reported strong GDP and consumer spending bolster resilience, though accelerated productivity or technology adoption could reduce short-run hiring without reflecting a traditional cyclical downturn.
Bullish
- Chicago Fed indicator estimates unemployment roughly unchanged at 4.36% in October.
- Hiring, layoff, and vacancy rates from private signals show broad stability.
- GDP and consumer spending remain strong, supporting labor demand.
Bearish
- Payroll job creation has materially weakened, signaling potential cooling in the labor market.
- Low hiring combined with high uncertainty could presage a slowdown if firms delay spending.
- Government shutdown creates blind spots on inflation, increasing risk of mistimed rate cuts.
- Uncertainty around immigration/population flows complicates interpretation of employment numbers.
People mentioned
Austin GoolsbeeSteveBarack Obama